Research Article| Volume 12, ISSUE 2, P95-106, April 1998

A restraint on restraints: The need to reconsider the use of restrictive interventions

      This paper is only available as a PDF. To read, Please Download here.
      Children with behavior problems are put in units with milieu therapy for the support and guidance of a specialized health care team, supposedly experts in the care of children with these unique and urgent needs. The reality of such units, however, is that those with the most contact with the children are often inadequately prepared, both in terms of knowledge and skills, to manage disruptive behaviors. As a result, the milieu that is supposed to provide support and structure can actually exacerbate the trauma for the vulnerable child. Preliminary data are presented from an ongoing study that is investigating the experiences and memories of formerly hospitalized children. Three types of traumatic experiences are described: vicarious trauma, alienation from staff, and direct trauma. Many of the traumatic events endured by child patients are the result of an inappropriate use by staff of power and force. There was a marked lack of understanding by the children of why given interventions were used. Although coercive interventions are sometimes necessary, ethical, legal, and other professional considerations make it clear that more work is needed. Research to identify the patterns of lack of knowledge and skills, as well as to develop appropriate interventions are recommended.


        • Adams G.R.
        • Gullotta T.
        Adolescent Life Experiences.
        2nd Ed. Brooks/Cole, New York1989
        • Adler W.N.
        • Kreeger M.A.
        • Zigler P.
        Patient violence in a private psychiatric hospital.
        in: Lion J.R. Reid W.H. Assaults in Psychiatric Facilities. Gruene & Stratton, Pacific Grove, CA1983: 81-90
        • Bath H.
        The physical restraint of children: Is it therapeutic?.
        American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 1994; 64: 40-49
        • Blanch A.K.
        • Parrish J.
        Report on Round Table on Alternatives to Involuntary Treatment. National Institute of Mental Health, New York1992
        • Borreson S.
        Fraud suits still haunt hospital giant.
        Texas Lawyer. 1997; 12: 24-28
        • Braxton E.T.
        Angry children, frightened staff: Implications from training and staff development.
        in: Piazza D. When love is not enough: The management of covert dynamics in organizations that treat children and adolescents. The Hawthorne Press, Rockville, MD1995: 13-28
        • Burgess A.W.
        Psychiatric nursing: Promoting mental health.
        Appleton-Lange, New York, NY1997
        • Campbell M.
        • Gonzolez N.M.
        • Silva R.R.
        The pharmacologic treatment of conduct disorders and rage outbursts.
        Psychiatric Clinics of North America. 1992; 15: 69-85
        • Caraffa R.
        • Truckey E.
        • Golden F.
        A comparison of the effects of timeout with no stimulation versus timeout with stimulation on the return-to-task behavior of a six year old aggressive male student.
        Corrective and Social Psychiatry and Journal of Behavior Technology, Methods, and Therapy. 1974; 76: 40-45
        • Chamberlin J.
        An ex-patient's response to Soliday.
        Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders. 1985; 173: 288-289
        • Cohen L.J.
        Psychiatric hospitalization as an experience of trauma.
        Archives of Psychiatric Nursing. 1994; 8: 78-81
        • Cotton N.
        The developmental-clinical rationale for the use of seclusion in the psychiatric treatement of children.
        American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 1989; 59: 450-1044
        • Darnton N.
        Committed youth.
        Newsweek, July. 1989; 31: 66-69
        • Dodge K.A.
        • Price J.M.
        • Bachorowski J.
        • Newman J.P.
        Hostile attributional biases in severely aggressive adolescents.
        Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 1990; 99: 385-392
        • Erickson W.
        • Realmuto G.
        frequency of seclusion in an adolescent psychiatric unity.
        Journal of Clinical Psychiatry. 1983; 44: 238-241
      1. Eth S. Pynoos R.S. Post traumatic stress disorder in children. American Psychiatric Association Press, Stamford, CT1985
        • Evans L.
        • Strumpf
        Tying down the elderly: A review of the literature on physical restraints.
        Journal of the American Geriatric Society. 1989; 36: 65-74
        • Fisher W.A.
        Restraint and seclusion: A review of the literature.
        American Journal of Psychiatry. 1994; 151: 1584-1591
        • Goren S.
        What are the considerations for the use of seclusion and restraint with children and adolescents.
        Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Services. 1991; 29: 32-33
        • Goren S.
        • Singh N.N.
        • Best A.M.
        The aggression-coercion cycle: Use of seclusion and restraint in a child psychiatric hospital.
        Journal of Child and Family Studies. 1993; 2: 61-73
        • Goren S.
        • Curtis W.J.
        Staff members' beliefs about seclusion and restraint in child psychiatric hospitals.
        Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing. 1996; 9: 7-11
        • Goren S.
        • Abraham I.
        • Doyle N.
        Reducing violence in a child psychiatric hospital through planned organizational change.
        Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing. 1996; 9: 27-36
        • Gorman L.M.
        • Sultan D.F.
        • Raines M.L.
        Davis's Manual of Psychosocial Nursing. FA Davis Co., Washington, DC1996
        • Health Care Financing Administration
        Interpretive Guidelines: State Operations Manual Transmittal 250. Author, Philadelphia1992
        • Johnson B.S.
        Psychiatric Nursing: Adaptation and growth.
        4th ed. J.P. Lippincott, Washington, DC1997
        • Lapierre E.D.
        • Padgett J.
        What are the considerations of the use of seclusion and restraint with children and adolescents?.
        Journal of Psychosocial Nursing. 1991; 29: 33-36
        • Lincoln Y.
        • Guba E.
        Naturalistic inquiry.
        Sage Publishing, Philadelphia1985
        • Mandoki M.W.
        • Sumner G.S.
        • Matthews-Ferrari K.
        Evaluation and treatment of rage in children and adolescents.
        Child Psychiatry and Human Development. 1992; 22: 227-235
        • Mandsdorf I.J.
        Reinforcer isolation: An alternative to subject isolation in timeout from positive reinforcement.
        Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry. 1977; 12: 391-393
        • McFarland G.K.
        • Wasli E.L.
        • Gercty E.K.
        Nursing Diagnosis and Process in Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing.
        Lippincott, Newbury Park, CA1997
        • Miles M.B.
        • Huberman A.M.
        Qualitative Data Analysis.
        2nd Ed. Sage, Philadelphia1994
        • Miller D.
        The management of misbehavior by seclusion.
        Milieu Therapy. 1986; 4: 13-18
        • Miller D.
        The management of misbehavior by seclusion.
        Residential Treatement for Children and Youth. 1986; 4: 63-73
        • Mohr W.K.
        Psychiatric nurses work experiences in troubled environmental contexts.
        Archives of Psychiatric Nursing. 1996; 10: 197-206
        • Mohr W.K.
        The outcomes of corporate greed.
        Image: Journal of Nursing Scholarship. 1997; 29: 39-47
      2. Mohr, W.K. (in press). Unexpected outcomes of child psychiatric hospitalization. Issues in Mental Health Nursing.

        • Mohr W.K.
        • Mahon M.M.
        Dirty hands: The underside of marketplace medicine.
        Advances in Nursing Science. 1996; 19: 28-37
        • Mohr W.K.
        • Noone M.J.
        Deconstructing progress notes in psychiatric settings.
        Archives of Psychiatric Nursing. 1997; 11: 325-331
        • Morrison E.F.
        The tradition of toughness: a study of nonprofessional nursing care in psychiatric settings.
        Image: Journal of Nursing Scholarship. 1990; 22: 32-38
        • Moss R.J.
        • LaPuma J.
        The ethics of mechanical restraints.
        Hastings Center Report. 1991; 21: 22-25
        • Newcorn J.H.
        • Strain J.
        Adjustment disorder in children and adolescents.
        Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 1992; 31: 318-327
        • Obholzer A.
        The residential setting in psychotherapeutic work with adolescents.
        Residential Treatment for Children and Youth. 1995; 13: 5-12
        • Perrow C.
        Hospitals: Technology, structure and goals.
        in: March J.G. Handbook of organizations. Rand-McNally, Thousand Oaks, CA1965: 45-60
        • Peterson E.
        • Gray K.
        • Weinstein S.
        A look at adolescent treatment in a time of change.
        in: Kent M.W. Rolf J.E. Primary prevention of Psychopathology. University Press of New England, Chicago, IL1994: 49-74
        • Rubenstein H.
        Standards of medical care based on consensus rather than evidence: The case of routine bedrail use for the elderly.
        Law Medicine and Health Care. 1983; 11: 271-276
        • Rutter M.
        Protective factors in childrens' responses to stress and disadvantage.
        in: Kent M.W. Rolf J.E. Primary Prevention in Psycopathology. University of New England Press, Hanover, N.H.1979: 49-74
        • Rutter M.
        Psychopathology and development: Links between childhood and adult life.
        in: Rutter M. Hersov L. Child and Adolescent Psychiatry: Modern Approaches. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Hanover, NH1985: 720-739
        • Rutter M.
        • Giller H.
        Juvenile delinquency: Trends and Perspectives.
        Penguin Press, Boston, MA1983
        • Sage Publications
        QSR NUD.IST. Author, Harmonsworth, UK1995
        • Sandelowski M.
        The problem of rigor in qualitative research.
        Advances in Nursing Science. 1986; 8: 27-37
        • Smith M.
        Senate panel condemns “rage reduction” psychiatric treatment.
        The Houston Chronicle. 1992, March 5; : A23
        • Smith M.
        Few doctors lost licenses over scandal.
        Houston Chronicle. 1997, March 24; : 1A
        • Smith M.
        Few doctors lost licenses over scandal.
        Houston Chronicle. 1997, March 24; : 8A
        • Stake R.E.
        The Art of Case Study Research.
        Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA1995
        • State of Texas D.H.H.S.
        Texas State Interim Committee Report on Private Psychiatric, Substance Abuse and Medical Rehabilitation Services. Author, Thousand Oaks, CA1992, Nov
        • Stuart G.
        • Sundeen G.
        Principles and practice of psychiatric nursing.
        5th Ed. Mosby, Austin, TX1995
        • Stewart J.T.
        • Myers W.C.
        • Burket R.C.
        • Lyles W.B.
        A review of the pharmacotherapy of aggression in children and adolescents.
        Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 1990; 29: 269-277
        • Tardiff K.
        The psychiatric uses of seclusion and restraint.
        American Psychiatric Press, St. Louis1984
        • Werner E.E.
        • Smith R.S.
        Vulnerable but invincible: A study of resilient children.
        McGraw-Hill, Washington, DC1982
        • Yin R.
        Case Study Research: Design and Method.
        Sage Publications, NY1989
        • Zimbardo P.
        • Haney C.
        • Banks W.C.
        A Pirandellian prison.
        The New York Times Magazine. 1973, April; 3: 10-12
        • Zimbardo P.
        • Haney C.
        • Banks W.C.
        A Pirandellian prison.
        The New York Times Magazine. 1973, April; 3: 18